Sophists


Gorgias. Encomium of Helen

Isocrates_LXXIIv.jpg
Isocrates

  • “Encomium of Helen” would have been very controversial – Helen would have been one of the most hated women in Greece – Apologia for Helen – did it to show off
  • use dialectic in teaching – inventing arguments for and against a proposition
  • function of language in inducing belief
    • Linguistic devices for manipulation – poetic devices
    • language can be crafted for specific purposes – powerful speech is not simply the result of the speaker’s inspiration or the audience’s transport
  • Believed that provisional knowledge is the only knowledge we can attain – no such thing as transcendent knowledge
    • Rhetoric helps us understand the world through ethos and pathos-based appeals
  • language can be crafted to suit particular purposes

Isocrates. "Antidosis"

  • Was a contemporary of Plato who opened the first school of rhetoric in Athens.
    • Saw himself primarily as an educator
    • Sophistic - Education can improve the natural talents of all comers – and that it should be useful to the state
    • wanted to create civic leaders
    • Did not claim to impart wisdom – counter Sophists and Plato
  • Morality
    • rhetoric is used to speak noble, virtuous ideas and implement them in civic society
    • morality is not taught but is inspired by teachers (emulation)
  • Importance of amplification and smoothness of style
  • First to write down and circulate speeches
  • 3 factors of rhetorical training – three elements requisite to being a valuable citizen
    • natural talent
    • extensive practice in varied situations
    • education in basic principles of rhetoric
  • Rhetoric should be used to advance Greek ideas and institutions